4 printings listed in our catalog, from newest to oldest.
Phyrexia: All Will Be OneONE · No. 3832023-02-10
Card text
Instant
Up to one target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn. If X is 5 or more, return a creature card with mana value X or less from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.
You can cast Black Sun's Twilight without a target (presumably with X equal to 5 or more) just to return a creature card. However, if you do choose a target, and that target is illegal at the time the spell tries to resolve, the spell won't resolve and none of its effects will happen. You won't get to return a creature card to the battlefield.
2023-02-04 · Wizards of the Coast
The creature card you return, if any, isn't a target of Black Sun's Twilight. You choose it as Black Sun's Twilight resolves if X is 5 or more.
🍪 Tapt uses cookies and measurement tools to make the site work. With your consent, it also uses optional ones to understand how the site is used and to improve it. Learn more.
Essential cookieKeeps you signed in from one page to the next. Without it, the site does not work.
Always on
Internal audience measurementPages visited, cards searched, approximate city, and an anonymous session token that links your actions for the length of your visit (random, with no name or IP address, erased when you close the tab). Stays with Tapt, never shared. If refused, traffic is still counted but nothing is tied to you.
Third-party toolGoogle Analytics (traffic statistics, shortened IP address). It sets its own cookies and receives data from your visit, sometimes outside Quebec. If refused, nothing is loaded. You can subscribe to the newsletter either way: your address is only sent when you click Subscribe.